Could ASI Create Pets Even Cuter Than Cats?

[AGI]

ASIpets.jpg

Understanding ASI and Its Capabilities

Artificial Superintelligence (ASI) refers to a level of intelligence that not only matches but vastly surpasses the most gifted human minds in every field, including scientific creativity, general wisdom, and social skills. Unlike Narrow AI or even Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), ASI would possess the capacity for recursive self-improvement, meaning it could redesign its own architecture to become more efficient and capable over time without human intervention. Theoretical models suggest ASI could solve complex biological, genetic, and behavioral problems that are beyond our current capabilities, making it theoretically possible for ASI to influence or create new species, including domesticated animals.

Current AI developments, such as DeepMind’s AlphaFold predicting protein structures with high precision or OpenAI's advancements in multimodal models, illustrate early steps toward the kind of rapid scientific discovery that ASI could perform on a dramatically larger scale. However, as of 2025, true ASI has not yet been developed, and its arrival remains speculative, though many experts suggest it could occur within this century.

Biological Engineering and Pet Creation

Today, genetic engineering is progressing at a steady pace. Technologies such as CRISPR-Cas9 allow scientists to edit genomes with relative precision, already leading to breakthroughs like disease-resistant crops and experimental gene therapies for inherited diseases. In animals, gene editing has been used to create hypoallergenic cats (though commercial success has been limited) and to explore possibilities like glow-in-the-dark rabbits by inserting jellyfish DNA.

If ASI emerged, its understanding of genetics, molecular biology, and epigenetics could be so deep that it would make today’s most advanced laboratories seem primitive by comparison. ASI could, in theory, design entirely new life forms with targeted traits such as enhanced cuteness, optimized health, greater emotional bonding capacity with humans, and even a custom-tailored lifespan to suit human companionship needs.

Nevertheless, biological engineering is constrained by hard physical limits. Evolutionary biology teaches us that certain traits, like large eyes in proportion to head size or juvenile features persisting into adulthood (neoteny), are universally perceived as cute across mammalian species. These limits suggest that while ASI could refine and amplify cuteness in pets, it would still operate within the framework of biological possibilities.

Psychological Foundations of Cuteness

The perception of "cuteness" is not arbitrary; it is rooted in deep evolutionary psychology. Human brains respond strongly to features associated with infants: large, forward-facing eyes, small noses, round faces, and soft, clumsy movements. These features trigger caregiving behaviors, an essential survival mechanism for our own young.

Cats, in particular, have been evolutionary champions in exploiting these instincts. Studies have shown that the frequency and tone of a cat’s meow can mimic a human infant’s cry, appealing directly to our nurturing tendencies. Domesticated cats have undergone subtle but consistent morphological changes over millennia, leading to rounder faces and softer fur compared to their wild ancestors.

An ASI could analyze these psychological triggers in incredible depth, identifying undiscovered or underexploited traits that heighten the cuteness response. It could design animals with specific vocal ranges, textures of fur optimized to human touch receptors, or even subtle scent markers that enhance bonding. In this sense, yes, ASI could create pets that many would perceive as cuter than cats by systematically optimizing every factor that influences human emotional reactions.

Ethical Considerations of Creating New Pets

Even if ASI had the technical capacity to create ultra-cute pets, ethical questions would arise immediately. Humanity already debates the morality of breeding animals for appearance at the expense of health, as seen in some dog breeds suffering from breathing issues, joint problems, or other genetic disorders due to selective breeding.

ASI, depending on its goals and programming, might prioritize animal welfare in its designs, eliminating the chronic health issues that plague many domesticated species today. It could create pets that are not only emotionally satisfying for humans but also fundamentally healthier and happier than any existing species.

However, the creation of entirely new sentient beings raises profound ethical challenges. Would these creatures have rights? How would society regulate their breeding, ownership, and welfare? These questions, already complex when dealing with genetically modified animals today, would become even more urgent if entirely novel, highly intelligent pets were involved.

Technological Alternatives to Biological Pets

It is also important to consider that ASI might not focus solely on biological pets. The field of robotics and synthetic biology could converge to create robotic companions that mimic biological life with astonishing realism. Already, companies like Boston Dynamics and Sony (with its robotic dog Aibo) have demonstrated robots capable of evoking emotional responses from humans, though they remain crude compared to living animals.

With ASI’s capabilities, synthetic pets could be developed that are visually and tactilely indistinguishable from real animals, exhibiting complex emotional behaviors, adaptive learning, and even forming deep attachments with human owners. Synthetic life forms would avoid many ethical issues related to breeding, lifespan, and suffering, offering an alternative path to the ultimate cute companion.

Nevertheless, for many people, the knowledge that a creature is not "alive" in the traditional biological sense might limit emotional bonding. Psychological studies indicate that humans form stronger attachments to beings they perceive as sentient and vulnerable, traits inherently tied to biological life.

Environmental and Social Impacts

The introduction of new ultra-cute pets, whether biological or synthetic, would have broad impacts on society and the environment. Domesticated species already have significant environmental footprints. Cats, for example, are estimated to kill billions of birds and small mammals annually in some regions, causing serious ecological imbalances.

ASI-designed pets could potentially be engineered to minimize environmental disruption, perhaps through controlled dietary needs, behavioral programming that limits hunting instincts, or even biological design choices that prevent the need for outdoor roaming.

Socially, the emergence of a "cuter-than-cats" pet could shift global pet ownership trends dramatically. Entire industries — pet food, veterinary care, pet accessories — might reorient around the new species. Emotional attachments that have culturally centered around cats and dogs for thousands of years could expand to include beings designed specifically to maximize human emotional satisfaction.

Yet cultural factors also play a role. In some societies, certain animals are revered, while others are ignored or even reviled. How different cultures would accept or reject ASI-created pets would depend on deep-seated traditions, religious beliefs, and personal values.

Timeline for Possibility

Speculation about when ASI might emerge varies widely among experts. Surveys conducted among AI researchers show predictions ranging from a few decades to several centuries, with a significant portion believing there is a 50% chance of AGI by 2060. Since ASI would likely follow AGI relatively quickly, the mid-to-late 21st century is often cited as a plausible window.

Genetic engineering technologies are advancing rapidly even without ASI. It is conceivable that rudimentary forms of designer pets, though not ASI-created, could emerge within the next 20 to 30 years. However, true ASI-designed pets, optimized at the deepest biological and emotional levels, would likely require the full realization of ASI, which remains speculative at present.

A New Era of Companionship Awaits

While ASI could, in theory, create pets that surpass cats in perceived cuteness, the realization of such creations would depend on a convergence of deep biological understanding, ethical frameworks, societal acceptance, and technological maturity. ASI’s capabilities would far exceed current genetic engineering techniques, allowing for optimization of emotional bonding traits beyond anything natural evolution has produced.

However, technical feasibility does not guarantee social or ethical acceptance. Humanity would need to grapple with profound questions about life, rights, and our relationship with creatures of our own design. Cats have ruled our hearts for millennia, and even an ASI might find it challenging to create a successor capable of dethroning them in every human heart.